What Are You Paying Your Advisor To Manage?
By Alex Martinez on November 4, 2026

Dear Clients and Friends, I don’t like Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) or Index Fund Portfolios.
There, I said it.
I especially don’t like seeing an advisor put a client into a collection of ETFs or index funds, charge an asset management fee, and call it investment management.
What exactly are they managing?
The investor owns the good, the bad, and the ugly. There is little thought given to the individual companies. There is no conviction behind each holding. The portfolio owns everything because the index says to own everything.
That might be acceptable for someone managing their own money. It is inexpensive, simple, and easy to maintain.
But if that person is also paying an advisor an ongoing percentage of their assets, I think the advisor should be doing more.
I regularly meet people with millions of dollars invested in cookie-cutter portfolios filled with passive, low-cost products. The products may be inexpensive, but once an advisory fee is added, the overall relationship is no longer low-cost.
If you own an S&P 500 ETF and pay an advisor 1% to hold it, that fee creates an additional hurdle before you receive your net return. You should be able to ask what you are receiving in exchange for it.
“Your account went up” is not a sufficient answer. The market may have gone up. That does not tell you whether your advisor made a good decision—or made any decision at all.
Real investment management should start with the financial plan.
How much return does the client actually need? How much risk can they afford to take? How much will they need from the portfolio over the next several years?
For our retired clients, we generally want at least five years of anticipated income distributions held in bonds or cash. The remaining portfolio can then be constructed around the client’s goals, required return, available assets, and tolerance for risk.
We are not trying to beat an index every year. We are not promising that every holding will work. We are not promising that our portfolios will keep pace with whatever benchmark happens to be leading the market.
There are no guarantees.
Our objective is to put each client in a position to pursue the return their financial plan requires while taking as little risk as we reasonably believe is necessary.
That requires understanding portfolio construction, asset allocation, and the individual investments we own. It requires conviction. Most importantly, it requires knowing why a client owns what they own.
Too many investors do not.
They assume all advisors invest money the same way. They believe their advisor must be doing a good job because their account is up. But they cannot explain what they own, why they own it, or what their advisor is actually doing for the fee.
If you want to build your own low-cost ETF portfolio, that is a reasonable choice. I simply don’t believe you should pay an advisor an asset management fee to do something you could easily do yourself. If you only need financial planning, pay separately for financial planning.
But investment management should involve actual management.
You spent decades building your wealth. Dropping it into a generic basket and charging a fee on top of it is not good enough for me.
Invest with intention,
Jake