Where Are Your Retirement Dollars Going?
By Luke Sullivan on November 6, 2026

Where Are Your Retirement Dollars Going?
The S&P 500 is sort of like the Big 10 conference in college athletics. How might you ask? Well, they both have a number in the name that is meant to represent the number of universities, or companies, within the grouping. The Big 10 houses 18 full-member universities, far surpassing what its name suggests. The reason for that is none of our concern, but I wanted to bring it up because it’s the best conference (debatably), and it shares that in common with its stock market equivalent: The S&P 500. What it also shares in is the fact that the S&P 500 actually houses anywhere from 503-505 companies at a given time, so once again, not what its name suggests. Alright, that’s enough filibustering… what you’re here for is retirement planning, and what we’re focused on today is a lesser-known fact about the most well-known index in the world of Wall St.
Source | www.bigten.org as of August 2, 2024
Source | www.spglobal.com as of August 31, 2026
Cap-Weighted S&P 500
There isn’t just one S&P 500 index, there is actually two, but one of them is used repeatedly as the ‘benchmark’ for what we compare stock returns against, and as the investment vehicle for most employer-sponsored plans. That benchmark is known as the ‘cap-weighted S&P 500 index’. Cap-weighted refers to how the weighting of each stock is assigned to the overall index. Think about it this way: not every company in the S&P 500 is the same size, obviously there are giants like Nvidia and Apple, but there are also much smaller companies that contribute to the S&P’s overall returns as well. The cap-weighted S&P 500 ignores the general size of each company and solely looks at the contribution of each company to the overall return. In 2026, this caused a bloated weighting toward the tech stocks, as the ‘Magnificent 7’ in the S&P currently make up ~35% of the index. This trend won’t reverse as long as these mega companies continue gaining a larger and larger slice of the market. The way we are going right now with seemingly endless capital expenditure pointed at Artificial Intelligence, don’t be surprised if the ‘Mag 7’ surpasses a 40% share of the index by this time next year.
Source | www.ssga.com as of October 28, 2026
Equal-Weight S&P 500
What about the ‘equal-weight S&P 500’? Well, the equal-weight focuses each company evenly within the index, so roughly 0.2% per company. Even as the earnings of the mega companies, the Magnificent 7, grow, the equal-weight S&P is rebalanced every quarter to ensure there is no bloating. With this rebalancing comes higher trading costs, which can adversely affect your returns. Over the long run, this matters more than it does over a short period, but most investors aren’t paying attention to this as much as they are the actual returns.
Source | www.spglobal.com as of April 20, 2026
Source | www.spglobal.com as of July 31, 2024
Why does this matter?
In October, we saw a staggering difference in return between the cap-weighted and equal-weighted indexes, 5.85% to be exact. This is a massive difference over the course of 31 days! You could say the market was a bit spooked by concerns over AI. The rocket ship that is the AI-buildout caused the tech stocks to hit a speedbump. What goes up quickly seems to go down just as quickly, and tech stocks are no exception here. So far this year, the cap-weighted S&P 500 has returned 11.1% for its investors, with the equal-weight S&P 500 quietly surpassing that at 16.2%, mostly due to the October tech pullback. I’m not referring to the October hiccup as an omen for a crash, but it is worth mentioning as tech stocks have a way of moving in tandem and causing chaos (up and down) at inopportune times.
Source | www.talkmarkets.com as of October 31, 2026
Source | www.ccmg.com as of November 5, 2026
Source | www.nasdaq.com as of November 2, 2026
Now, as I mentioned last week with the midterm elections, legislative changes could add fuel to the tech fire if states and counties stand their ground (literally) and vote against the construction of data centers. This isn’t a bag-on-tech segment, but when your portfolio is heavily concentrated in tech companies, you must take the really good with the really bad, instead of just the good with the bad.
I’m of the belief it is irresponsible to invest your money without knowing what you own, so, next time you see a fraction of your bi-weekly paycheck dive head-first into the S&P 500, just know that you too are a tech investor, even if you didn’t mean to be.